Greatest Chief Justices

Chief Justice John Roberts–A Massive Disappointment Greatly Responsible For Loss Of Supreme Court Credibility!

Chief Justice John Roberts, selected by President George W. Bush in 2005, came on the Supreme Court perceived as a moderate conservative.

For the past 21 plus years, he has veered noticeably to the Far Right, greatly disappointing millions of Americans, and often being indistinguishable from Associate Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito in their disgraceful extremism.

Occasionally, he has sided with liberal Associate Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Kentanji Brown Jackson, and has been in the majority occasionally with them, and either Associate Justice Amy Coney Barrett or Brett Kavanaugh, but sadly, not enough of the time.

So the Supreme Court has been harmed in public opinion, at an all time low, as they have taken actions to backtrack on civil rights, racial and gender equality, and have, shockingly, in Trump V US (2024), given Presidents broad immunity for their actions.

This author and blogger has consistently tried to give Roberts slack, but it has reached a point that makes it no longer possible to do so.

Roberts has permanently besmirched his reputation and that of the Court, and only when he, Thomas, and Alito leave the Court will there be the ability to restore the dignity and respect that the Supreme Court has usually had.

So the sooner Roberts (in 22nd year), Thomas (in 36th year), and Alito (in his 21st year) retire, the better it will be for the image of the Supreme Court.

For sure, Roberts will NOT go down as one of the 7 greatest Chief Justices, which would include:

John Marshall (1801-1835)
Salmon P. Chase (1864-1873)
William Howard Taft (1921-1930)
Charles Evans Hughes (1930-1941)
Harlan F. Stone (1941-1946)
Earl Warren (1953-1969)
Warren E. Burger (1969-1986)

And without any debate, the greatest would be John Marshall, Earl Warren, Charles Evans Hughes and Warren E. Burger, in that ranked order.

The good news is that, assuming there is not a last minute retirement by Thomas or Alito, before the 119th Congress ends in December, that any future Supreme Court appointment will NOT be confirmed under Donald Trump by the Democratic Senate of the 120th Congress, unless totally acceptable.

And with the strong likelihood that a Democrat will be elected President in 2028, it means all Supreme Court nominees for the foreseeable future will be Democratic and liberal in nature, transforming the right wing Court to a balanced Supreme Court.