The Final Obama-McCain Debate

The final Obama-McCain debate was the best of the three, in the sense it was the most interesting and the most direct interaction between the candidates.  It also was the best performance by far of Senator McCain, without any doubt.  The first twenty minutes of the debate were his best, but after that, Obama clearly performed better.  Also, Bob Schieffer of CBS News was the best moderator of all the debates, as I see it, a tribute to his long, distinguished career.

Despite the improved performance of Senator McCain, it is clear that  Senator Obama won the debate on points.  Senator McCain was on the offense, but Senator Obama was solid in his defense when challenged, and he was clear in his advocacy on health care and education and his economic plans.  He gave a spirited response also to the William Ayers controversy and to his position on abortion in the Illinois Legislature. 

McCain’s job was to win over independents, and in that regard, it is highly doubtful that he accomplished that goal.  His constant references to "Joe the Plumber" were tedious and overdone and was unlikely to appeal to many voters or observers.  Also, his body language demonstrated what seemed to be a sense of contained fury and anger which did not come across well.  Obama again presented himself as cool, calm and collected, traits one would wish a President would have, particularly with the overwhelming economic crisis now faced by the nation.  Obama appeared more statesmanlike and has, as a result of these three debates, given confidence to many who might have had doubts about him before these events.

In conclusion, this final debate did not change the basic dynamic, and now it is just 19 days to go until we are likely to elect Senator Obama as the next President, with Senator Joe Biden by his side.  Senator McCain has done good duty in his Senate years, and hopefully, he will be a strong participant next year in the Senate in assisting the new President in his goal to revive the American economy and get this nation out of the greatest crisis since the Great Depression.  The hope is that in these final 19 days, the campaigning by the McCain Palin ticket will elevate to a dignified level with real discussion of issues, rather than personal attacks.

2 comments on “The Final Obama-McCain Debate

  1. Cassie October 16, 2008 11:28 pm
    I didn’t watch the final debate but your coverage of it comes across as balanced and fair. Thanks!
  2. Michael Brian October 16, 2008 11:28 pm
      McCain’s posture was reminiscent of Al Gore in 2000 with the eyerolling and all-too-apparent exasperation at his opponent’s responses. Many conservative pundits obviously tried to claim a McCain victory, since it was easily his best performance, while claiming that Obama came off "professorial", a now tired and overused term which means nothing except that a candidate on the left is using too much information or coming off too authoritative. However, I found McCain to be condescending and erratic. His answers after the issue of the campaign came up often became incoherent, a patchwork of very loosely connected points and one liners. It was obvious he was trying to be tougher with Obama, but his offensive strategy only worked until he got worked up emotionally.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.